Subscribe to our newsletter

The Role of Wine Ratings and Critics in Fine Wine Investment

Navigating the World of Expert Opinions

6/29/20232 min read


Wine ratings and critics play an influential role in shaping the fine wine market, guiding investors and collectors on their journey to build a profitable wine portfolio. In this article, we'll analyze the impact of these expert opinions and provide insights on how investors can use this information to make informed decisions about their wine portfolios. To stay updated on the latest trends and analysis in the fine wine market, subscribe to our WineLux newsletter [link].

The Power of Scores and Critics:

Wine scores from leading critics, such as those published by Liv-ex during the Bordeaux En Primeur 2022 campaign, can significantly impact a wine's market value and desirability. These scores act as a benchmark, helping investors and collectors identify exceptional wines worth adding to their portfolios. High scores from renowned critics like Robert Parker, James Suckling, and Jancis Robinson can propel a wine's price and demand, while lower scores may deter potential buyers.

Understanding the Scoring Systems:

It's essential to understand the scoring systems used by critics, as each may have a unique approach to evaluating wines. The 100-point scale, popularized by Robert Parker, has become a standard in the wine industry. A score above 90 points indicates an outstanding wine, while a perfect score of 100 points signifies a truly exceptional and collectible bottle. Other critics may use a 20-point scale or employ stars, medals, or other rating systems. Familiarizing yourself with each critic's methodology will allow you to make more informed decisions when using their ratings to guide your investments.

Diversifying Your Sources:

While relying on a single critic's opinion may be tempting, diversifying your sources of information can provide a more comprehensive understanding of a wine's potential. Different critics may have varying preferences, and a wine that receives a high score from one may not resonate with another. By considering multiple critics' opinions, you'll gain a more balanced perspective and reduce the risk of making investment decisions based on a single viewpoint.

Contextualizing Ratings and Reviews:

Although wine ratings and reviews are valuable tools, they should not be the sole determinant when making investment decisions. It's crucial to consider other factors, such as a wine's provenance, vintage, and the reputation of the producer. Additionally, personal preferences should play a role, as investing in wines that you genuinely appreciate and enjoy can bring greater satisfaction and a deeper connection to your portfolio.


Wine ratings and critics provide invaluable guidance for investors and collectors in the fine wine market. By understanding the scoring systems, diversifying your sources, and contextualizing ratings and reviews, you can use expert opinions to make informed decisions about your wine portfolio. To explore more about the world of fine wine investment, consider reading our article on "Building a Profitable Wine Portfolio: Expert Strategies for Wine Enthusiasts and Investors" [link].

Don't forget to subscribe to our WineLux newsletter [link] to stay updated on the latest trends, insights, and expert analysis in the world of fine wine investment.

Happy investing, and cheers! 🍷